New Flavors Created Weekly

Weekly Menu

Explore Butterspell’s latest menu highlights, for our pop-ups. made fresh in NYC.

                  Next Week Menu

Cookies

Classic chocolate chip

$3.25

Big soft and chewy with a mix of Milk chocolate chips and Dark chocolate chunks.

Sugar cookie

$3.00

Simple and bursting with flavor this is not your grandmothers sugar cookies.

Caramel cookie

$3.25

Soft and simple with a caramel core and topped with a  salted caramel drizzle who can want more.

Snickerdoodle

$3.00

Soft, Chewy and Tender this cookie is rolled with warm spices

Cakes slices

Chocolate fudge cake

$6.50

Chocolate cake base with a chocolate fudge filling and frosted with a chocolate buttercream

Vanilla cake

$6.50

A most sponge cake with a vanilla buttercream

Tres leches

$4.00

A light sponge cake soaked in a rich blend of three milks topped with whipped cream

Red velvet cake

$6.50

A classic favorite with moist red velvet cake, perfectly paired with a smooth cream cheese frosting

Strawberry Short cake

$3.25

Fluffy vanilla sponge layered with fresh strawberries 

Cupcakes/Brownies

Chocolate fudge cupcake

$4.50

This cupcake is filled with chocolate fudge and frosted with a chocolate butter cream

Vanilla cupcake

$4.50

 This cupcake is filled with whipped cream and frosted with vanilla buttercream

Classic Brownie

$4.00

Three words Simple, Chewy and Fudgy

Next Week Menu Highlights

Caramel cookie

Soft and simple with a caramel core and topped with a  salted caramel drizzle who can want more.

$3.25 each

Tres Leches

A light sponge cake soaked in a rich blend of three milks topped with whipped cream

$4.00 each

Chocolate fudge cupcake

This cupcake is filled with chocolate fudge and frosted with a chocolate butter cream

$4.50 each

This Week Featured Flavors

Freshly Baked, Just for You

Be updated on our new menu every week by subscribing to us. Subscribe with us for updates, Birthday specials and more .

Contact Us